Most of the themes suck there. What I want is a simplistic theme that's finely crafted just like Thesis for wordpress and similar top-notch themes.
Simple, white, mega menu, and typography masterpiece.
I think themeforest has a Magento themes section.
Thanks feketegy for the suggestion. I found my perfect theme here: http://fastdivision.com/themes/avalanche/
But themeforest does come very competitive in regards to your budget. The themes aren't bad, just not great.