I was wondering based on colour theory, readability, and typography standards is it okay or acceptable to have white text on a darker background, which is then on a black background?
I always thought it was preferred or better to have black / colour text on a white / light background? Thats why this input box I am typing in now has a white bg and black text by default, right?
What are you guys' thoughts and reasonings?
For thorough reading, I much prefer to have dark text on a light background. However, I can also easily read light colored text on a dark background. The following is an example of a site I find highly readable color wise: http://daringfireball.net/. Another example of a site I find highly readable but has the exact reverse combination is this one: http://www.456bereastreet.com/
Both sites do not use black and white, but slightly lighter shades. I prefer lighter shadings because my eyes are sensitive to light, ergo a hard black/white or white/black approach makes my eyes sore and strained in a matter of minutes. Unfortunately, many "purists" who claim that anything that isn't #000 or #fff is mere design idiocy do not account for people like me who suffer from light sensitivity.
With that said, I've not found a single source that has some hard facts regarding the matter without counter articles stating the opposite. There's been a thread here on SP some time ago where a couple of people with a form of dyslexia said they preferred light text on dark backgrounds, though far more people who have a case of dyslexia have claimed the exact opposite. An absolute answer to that question seems to be non-existent. The only conclusion I draw is that high contrast is mandatory regardless of the approach you use in the decision-making process.
Typography is an integral part of design. Think of all the different uses of typography on the web, from large headlines and bold blocks of text to smaller-sized text in body copy, and you’ll soon realize that not only is it a crucial part of a web design, but that it’s a pure combination of art and science. But in a dark background i think light colors are better.
I also suffer from light sensitivity and although I love the cleanness of white, I love it much more when I can read the text without my eyes crying all the time :lol:
Yes, me too. Pure white or pure black is sexy, but also mighty inconvenient.
I think the OP is oversimplifying his /her objective.
Aim for OPTIMAL contrast. You can achieve that either way ( going dart/on light OR light on dark) but remember that what you are going is for a differential not just simply black/white ( or one color and it's compliment, etc). Tho I too have heard that some folks preferred dark bg with light type.. I have found that this assumption came from the early CRT monitors in the 80s and 90s who could only render less than 300 levels of contrast.
Another thing to consider i s that contrast has meaning. In print I sometimes use the same weight text, but with diminished contrast to convey content that is subordinate to to content with higher contrast.
This topic is now closed. New replies are no longer allowed.