Thank you so much PaulOB - Grazie tanto PaulOB! Your fix worked 
Yes looks like some how i knocked the code you spotted was missing, apologies, its now in and it works Very happy, thank you again
Thank you so much PaulOB - Grazie tanto PaulOB! Your fix worked Yes looks like some how i knocked the code you spotted was missing, apologies, its now in and it works Very happy, thank you again