rhysickle — 2008-03-06T11:58:44-05:00 — #1
In xhtml/html am I allowed to put <p>, <h2> etc. tags inside <li></li> tags? I know this won't actually break the page, but is it semantically acceptable.
The answer may seem like an obvious "yes it's ok" but recently I was surprised to find out that putting text within a <blockquote> without also putting it in <p> tags is not allowed, so there are some pretty strict nesting rules around.
Cheers for any advice
chris_fuel — 2008-03-06T12:45:10-05:00 — #2
well, quoting the dtd for xhtml strict:
<!ENTITY % block
"p | %heading; | div | %lists; | %blocktext; | fieldset | table">
<!ENTITY % Block "(%block; | form | %misc;)*">
<!-- %Flow; mixes block and inline and is used for list items etc. -->
<!ENTITY % Flow "(#PCDATA | %block; | form | %inline; | %misc;)*">
So yes you could do so, and as %block; expands to %blocktext%, you could technically shove <hr>'s in there too (not sure why, seems kind of weird).
As for whether or not it's semantically correct is a different story. For li's to be li's, they need to be a list of something (hence why you might see a lot of menus done as li's and css'ed to look pretty, because menus are a list of links).
autisticcuckoo — 2008-03-06T12:49:54-05:00 — #3
It's perfectly all right to use those elements within a list item.
If you start mixing inline-level and block-level elements, then it's semantically doubtful, though. That applies both within a single list item and within the list as a whole.
In other words, if you have a block-level element as a child of an
li element, then all children of that
li – and all sibling
li elements – should be block-level.